Human Security
By All About Defense | Gabrielle Moura
Published Loading...
N/A views
N/A likes
AI Summary of "Human Security"
Get instant insights and key takeaways from this YouTube video by All About Defense | Gabrielle Moura.
Evolution of Security Concepts (1990s Context)
📌 The 1990s saw a shift in security debates, moving from State Security to focusing on Individual Security.
🌍 The United Nations Development Program (UNDP) institutionalized the concept of Human Security, linking it to the evolving idea of "development."
💥 The crisis of the national developmentalism discourse led to the rise of neoliberalism and new development alternatives, strengthening the UNDP's platform.
Human Security Framework: Freedom from Fear and Necessity
💡 Human Security redefines security from a negative view (avoiding suffering/conflict) to a positive exercise fostering individual enjoyment of social life.
⚖️ This positive security is articulated around two inseparable concepts: freedom from fear and freedom from necessity.
🚫 Freedom from fear (negative security) means avoiding violence, but it's insufficient without addressing the structural issues causing desperation.
📈 Freedom from necessity involves creating opportunity structures (e.g., infrastructure, reducing misery and inequality) to prevent groups from resorting to violence for survival.
Historical Context: Development Discourse and Post-WWII Order
🏛️ Post-WWII order was fundamentally shaped by the concept of development, seen in Truman's vision for international cooperation to counter rivals.
🗺️ The initial development discourse replaced the metropolis/colony vertical division with a temporal one: developed vs. underdeveloped nations, implying the latter could change position.
📉 The liberal development model based on comparative advantage failed, leading to increasing dependence, which spurred the national developmentalism project in peripheral countries (like Brazil) in the 1960s.
The Rise of Human Development and Security
📉 The failure of national development projects in the 1980s (due to debt crises) led to the Washington Consensus and conditional lending.
📊 UNDP gained relevance by proposing a new, technical development discourse focusing on the individual's benefit rather than just GDP growth.
🔗 This led to the Human Development Index (HDI), which measures an individual's probability of accessing resources for autonomy.
⚠️ The World Bank's "Conflict Trap" report highlighted a correlation between poverty/inequality and violence, necessitating institutional stability measures alongside human development investments.
Responsibility to Protect (R2P) and Sovereignty
🛡️ The link between instability (poverty/violence cycle) and the need for intervention transitioned the discourse from Human Development to Human Security.
🌍 Human Security gained institutional space within the UN, but Third World countries viewed it suspiciously as a political appropriation by First World nations.
⚔️ Responsibility to Protect (R2P) redefines sovereignty, suggesting a state's primary objective is guaranteeing human security, relativizing traditional sovereignty if the state is unwilling or incapable.
🛑 R2P is seen by some as a speech legitimizing international intervention into sovereign states.
Key Points & Insights
➡️ The shift to Human Security emphasizes transforming the vicious cycle of violence/poverty into a virtuous cycle by ensuring institutional stability.
➡️ Freedom from fear and freedom from necessity are mutually reinforcing pillars for achieving comprehensive individual security.
➡️ The concept of underdevelopment (post-WWII) was inherently temporal, suggesting delayed modernization, unlike the fixed hierarchical position of a colony.
➡️ The R2P doctrine fundamentally challenges traditional state sovereignty by prioritizing the guarantee of human security for citizens.
📸 Video summarized with SummaryTube.com on Nov 16, 2025, 18:25 UTC
Related Products
Find relevant products on Amazon related to this video
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases
📜Transcript
Loading transcript...
📄Video Description
TranslateUpgrade
In this video we’ll talk about Human Security.
First, we’ll see how it is associated with a debate on transformations related to security in the 1990s.
In this decade, we observe a set of transformations that lead to a reflection on State Security and Individual Security.
In addition, there is a particular platform often associated with the concept of Human Security: the United Nations Development Program platform.
It institutionalized the concept of Human Security in very specific ways.
To understand why it articulates the concept in this way, it is necessary to understand the origin of the concept of “development” within this notion.
Thus, the “development problem” stands out.
In this, we have two important aspects: its novelty, it is very recent, something typical of the ordering after World War II.
Furthermore, within the way the order works, it is difficult to separate the idea of development from the idea of security, for example.
In this, the importance of highlighting the function of development as a functional part of this order is notorious.
It is necessary to speak of the beginning of the Cold War discourse, of cooperation for development, as Truman's vision of development ends up generating resistance that leads us to another concept, which is national developmentalism.
This concept is important in peripheral countries at a certain point in the Cold War, in which Brazil, for example, embraces the concept both from the point of view of its domestic policy as well as its foreign policy.
Finally, it is relevant to talk about the ideas that led to the crisis in the context of the 1990s.
The crisis of the national development discourse will lead, firstly, to a neoliberalism, and also to this development alternative that arises from the critique of national development
It is in this that the United Nations Development Programme gains strength in the architecture of the UN system as a whole.
It organizes this platform around this new discourse on human development that generates the need to transcend the reflection on the subject towards Human Security.
In the end, we will work on the dialogue between human development and human security.
It is the idea of understanding the problem of security through the relationship between the freedom of will and the freedom of necessity.
Finally, we will talk about the concept that arises from this agenda within the institutional architecture of the United Nations, which is the responsibility to protect.
It is the product of a set of works carried out in 2001, central to understanding the dilemma imposed on certain States, as it questions the sovereignty character of States.
It proposes a relativization of the notion of sovereignty.
music in this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WGM-IJYClKw
Full video URL: youtube.com/watch?v=I5xVDdab0Ys
Duration: 21:25
Recently Summarized Videos
💎Related Tags
human securityunited nationsresponsibility to protectUnited Nations Development Programme
Total Video Summary Page Visits :5
AI Summary of "Human Security"
Get instant insights and key takeaways from this YouTube video by All About Defense | Gabrielle Moura.
Evolution of Security Concepts (1990s Context)
📌 The 1990s saw a shift in security debates, moving from State Security to focusing on Individual Security.
🌍 The United Nations Development Program (UNDP) institutionalized the concept of Human Security, linking it to the evolving idea of "development."
💥 The crisis of the national developmentalism discourse led to the rise of neoliberalism and new development alternatives, strengthening the UNDP's platform.
Human Security Framework: Freedom from Fear and Necessity
💡 Human Security redefines security from a negative view (avoiding suffering/conflict) to a positive exercise fostering individual enjoyment of social life.
⚖️ This positive security is articulated around two inseparable concepts: freedom from fear and freedom from necessity.
🚫 Freedom from fear (negative security) means avoiding violence, but it's insufficient without addressing the structural issues causing desperation.
📈 Freedom from necessity involves creating opportunity structures (e.g., infrastructure, reducing misery and inequality) to prevent groups from resorting to violence for survival.
Historical Context: Development Discourse and Post-WWII Order
🏛️ Post-WWII order was fundamentally shaped by the concept of development, seen in Truman's vision for international cooperation to counter rivals.
🗺️ The initial development discourse replaced the metropolis/colony vertical division with a temporal one: developed vs. underdeveloped nations, implying the latter could change position.
📉 The liberal development model based on comparative advantage failed, leading to increasing dependence, which spurred the national developmentalism project in peripheral countries (like Brazil) in the 1960s.
The Rise of Human Development and Security
📉 The failure of national development projects in the 1980s (due to debt crises) led to the Washington Consensus and conditional lending.
📊 UNDP gained relevance by proposing a new, technical development discourse focusing on the individual's benefit rather than just GDP growth.
🔗 This led to the Human Development Index (HDI), which measures an individual's probability of accessing resources for autonomy.
⚠️ The World Bank's "Conflict Trap" report highlighted a correlation between poverty/inequality and violence, necessitating institutional stability measures alongside human development investments.
Responsibility to Protect (R2P) and Sovereignty
🛡️ The link between instability (poverty/violence cycle) and the need for intervention transitioned the discourse from Human Development to Human Security.
🌍 Human Security gained institutional space within the UN, but Third World countries viewed it suspiciously as a political appropriation by First World nations.
⚔️ Responsibility to Protect (R2P) redefines sovereignty, suggesting a state's primary objective is guaranteeing human security, relativizing traditional sovereignty if the state is unwilling or incapable.
🛑 R2P is seen by some as a speech legitimizing international intervention into sovereign states.
Key Points & Insights
➡️ The shift to Human Security emphasizes transforming the vicious cycle of violence/poverty into a virtuous cycle by ensuring institutional stability.
➡️ Freedom from fear and freedom from necessity are mutually reinforcing pillars for achieving comprehensive individual security.
➡️ The concept of underdevelopment (post-WWII) was inherently temporal, suggesting delayed modernization, unlike the fixed hierarchical position of a colony.
➡️ The R2P doctrine fundamentally challenges traditional state sovereignty by prioritizing the guarantee of human security for citizens.
📸 Video summarized with SummaryTube.com on Nov 16, 2025, 18:25 UTC
Related Products
Find relevant products on Amazon related to this video
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases
Loading Similar Videos...
Recently Summarized Videos
Get the Chrome Extension
Summarize youtube video with AI directly from any YouTube video page. Save Time.
Install our free Chrome extension. Get expert level summaries with one click.